The release date for the final two episodes of Agatha All Along on the eve of Halloween couldn’t be more fitting. This show, which has been simmering with spooky energy and supernatural intrigue, tells the story of witches gaining power through their coven, even as some of them have tragically lost their lives.
From the very start, the show has been filled with twists and turns, leaving viewers wondering what might happen next. With the finale on the horizon, it raises an exciting question: Will the show surprise us with something big at the end of the Witches’ Road?
Hold onto your hats, because the biggest surprise that Agatha All Along could deliver might be a major resurrection of key characters.
If this happens, it could rival the emotional farewell we saw when Wanda Maximoff (Elizabeth Olsen) released the town of Westview from her magical grip in WandaVision. But unlike Wanda’s tearful goodbye, this time, the show might be leading us toward a long-awaited reunion instead.
Every Witch Needs a Coven in Agatha All Along
As the Witches’ Road storyline unfolds, it’s clear that loss has played a big part in the journey. Three witches have died under heartbreaking circumstances along the way. Sharon Davis (played by Debra Jo Rupp) was too innocent and unprepared for the challenges ahead.
Alice (played by Ali Ahn) lost her life while trying to save Agatha (Kathryn Hahn). Lilia (played by Patti LuPone) sacrificed herself after finally embracing her divination gift. But is their death really the end? Is it possible that the prize awaiting the remaining witches at the end of the Witches’ Road is the resurrection of these fallen sisters?
Before anyone jumps to conclusions and dismisses this idea as an easy or anticlimactic plot device, it’s important to consider how the show has carefully emphasized the importance of the coven throughout its run. The show’s lore, especially the “Covenstead Rule,” has made it clear how essential covens are to a witch’s strength and survival.
The rule states, “Wherever you are, a coven there shall be,” meaning that witches are never truly alone. This theme is woven deeply into the series, and it’s hard to imagine that it would be discarded now, especially when the surviving witches are nearing the end of their perilous journey.
The Importance of a Coven
One of the most interesting characters in the show is Jen (played by Sasheer Zamata), a bound witch who initially resented the idea of joining a coven. For a long time, she avoided bonding with other witches, preferring to keep to herself.
However, as the story progresses, Jen is forced to join a coven, and this decision unlocks her hidden potential. During the first trial, she demonstrates remarkable abilities, such as healing a wounded Billy (another central character) later on. This transformation not only shows Jen’s growth but also highlights how powerful witches become when they work together as part of a coven.
This idea is reinforced in a memorable scene in Episode 5. The witches take to the skies on broomsticks, flying together under a full blood moon. The scene, which has been compared to a mix of Hocus Pocus and E.T., shows that magic is strongest when witches are united.
“We fly together or not at all!” Agatha shouts. This moment captures the heart of the series: witches are at their best when they’re part of a community. This sense of unity is what makes the idea of bringing back the fallen witches more than just a cheap plot twist.
If Sharon, Alice, and Lilia are resurrected, their deaths won’t feel meaningless. Instead, it would provide an opportunity for deeper storytelling and character development.
The Witches’ Road Needs to Bring the Dead Back
Bringing the dead back to life would continue the show’s homage to The Wizard of Oz, which has been a recurring influence throughout Agatha All Along. From the vibrant and magical Witches’ Road to the whimsical musical numbers and even the costume designs in Episode 7, the parallels are clear.
In The Wizard of Oz, Dorothy (played by Judy Garland) embarks on a journey of self-discovery in a fantasy world, which helps her face challenges in the real world once she wakes up.
Similarly, the Witches’ Road in Agatha All Along is a mystical and dangerous place where reality doesn’t apply, making it the perfect setting for self-discovery and change.
In Episode 2, Agatha asks Billy what he knows about covens. He responds, “Just that they’re drawn together by mysterious forces of fate, and that they’re the truest form of sisterhood.”
This idea of sisterhood has been fractured by the losses they’ve suffered along the Witches’ Road, but that doesn’t mean it can’t be restored. A resurrection could do more than give these witches a second chance at life; it could strengthen the bond between the surviving witches and highlight the power of their unity.
There’s also a possibility that the witches who return may come back stronger than they were before. Sharon, for example, might not have reached her full potential before her death. Throughout the series, there were hints that she was a “green witch,” someone with an affinity for plants and nature.
She had a “green thumb” and her connection to the earth was evident in her participation in the magical Ballad ceremony. If Sharon returns, her resurrection could unlock even greater magical abilities, making her a more formidable force.
Similarly, Alice’s story ended just as she was beginning a new chapter in her life. She had only recently broken her family’s curse, thanks to the support and strength of her coven. Her return would allow her to continue down this path of self-discovery and personal growth, showing how vital the coven’s support has been to her.
Lilia’s Sacrifice and the Power of Community
Lilia’s death, while tragic, was also a turning point in her character’s arc. For much of the series, she had struggled with her divination gift. Her mentor, Maestra (played by Laura Boccaletti), had warned her that “A witch requires a coven,” but Lilia resisted this idea.
She believed that it was better to live in isolation, like a hermit, than to rely on others. This was due to the pain and fear caused by her inability to prevent the tragic events she foresaw. Lilia couldn’t save her first coven, and this failure haunted her throughout her life.
However, by the time of her death, Lilia had finally accepted her gift for what it was. She understood that her power was to see, not to change. This realization allowed her to save her second coven by protecting Agatha, Billy, and Jen from the Salem Seven.
Her final words to Agatha — “When she calls you a coward, hit the deck” — could be a clue that she foresaw future events. If Lilia didn’t truly die in the castle, this hint might foreshadow her return. Her resurrection would allow her to continue using her gift for the greater good, and it would give her a chance to heal from the pain of her past.
Agatha Harkness: No Longer an Outsider
Throughout Agatha All Along, Agatha Harkness has been portrayed as a witch who has lived in isolation for centuries. Whether it was by her own actions or by the actions of others, Agatha has been alone for a long time.
However, the show has been hinting that she might not deserve the outcast status that has followed her for so long. Without the corrupting influence of the Darkhold, Agatha has the potential for redemption. And redemption, in her case, means becoming part of a community again. More specifically, Agatha needs a coven.
There have been subtle hints throughout the series that Agatha is no longer the lone wolf she once was. In Episode 2, there’s a visual clue that suggests Agatha can’t open the doors of the Witches’ Road by herself. She requires help from the other witches to succeed.
This moment is significant because it shows that even Agatha, who has always prided herself on her independence, needs the strength of her coven to move forward.
If the fallen witches do return, it would bring Agatha’s story full circle. In Episode 5, Jen corrects Agatha during the singing of “The Ballad,” reminding her that the lyrics are “Coven true,” not “Coven two.” This correction emphasizes that a coven isn’t just about numbers; it’s about the authenticity of the bond between the witches.
For Agatha, this could mean finding her place in a true sisterhood for the first time in centuries. The resurrection of Sharon, Alice, and Lilia wouldn’t just be a plot device; it would symbolize Agatha’s return to a community where she truly belongs.
What Does the Future Hold for Agatha All Along?
As the final episodes of Agatha All Along approach, fans are eagerly speculating about what the conclusion will bring. Will the Witches’ Road lead to the resurrection of the fallen witches? Will Agatha find redemption and rejoin the coven? While the show has kept its cards close to its chest, there are plenty of clues that suggest the story is heading in this direction.
Ultimately, Agatha All Along is a story about community, redemption, and the power of sisterhood. The show has consistently emphasized the importance of covens and the strength that comes from working together.
If the finale does bring back the fallen witches, it will be a fitting conclusion to a story that has always been about the bonds between these powerful women. Whether it’s through resurrection or through a deeper understanding of their shared power, one thing is certain: the witches of Agatha All Along are stronger together than they are apart.
