Episode 6 of Agatha All Along goes into Billy Maximoff’s complex past, adding more depth to the story. In last week’s episode, Agatha’s (Kathryn Hahn) mother, Evanora (Kate Forbes), returned and revealed a traumatic history.
This week, we see the return of Ralph Bohner (Evan Peters), Agatha’s fake husband, who she had also deeply hurt. This forms a painful cycle, but the episode still offers plenty of entertainment.
The episode begins with a significant moment in Billy’s life. Billy, who is now known as William Kaplan, is celebrating his bar mitzvah, a coming-of-age event.
It’s a warm and loving scene, where his supportive parents and close-knit community surround him. The design team added a thoughtful touch to the celebration, making the table decorations resemble the trees on the Witches’ Road. This attention to detail highlights the show’s impressive production design.
At the bar mitzvah, one of the guests is Lilia (played by Patti LuPone), who is there in a fortune-telling tent. Lilia tells William that a long journey lies ahead, one that will change him in profound ways.
While that seems fine at first, the atmosphere becomes tense when she reveals that William’s lifeline is broken in two. As the lights flicker, William feels understandably uneasy. Lilia tries to comfort him, explaining that this could mean many things, and reminds him that he is becoming a man.
She also mentions the Tower Reversed card, which confuses him. Lilia then hints that she just remembered something, but she doesn’t go into detail.
In a sweet moment, reminiscent of when Agatha told Billy she didn’t need to know his name to understand who he was, Lilia assures William that she doesn’t need psychic abilities to know that he is a good person.
She advises him to live in the present, as that’s all that’s certain. Before William leaves, Lilia secretly draws a sigil—a protective symbol—on a block of wood and slips it into his coat pocket, but she quickly forgets she did this.
On the way home, William’s father (Paul Adelstein) learns about an issue with the anomaly in Westview, which leads everyone to rush home in a panic. As they drive, William notices the sigil in his pocket and looks out the window to see a red light coming from the hex.
His mother (Maria Dizzia), distracted by the light, crashes the car into a tree. His parents immediately call for help, but William is gravely injured and bleeding in the backseat.
He dies from his injuries but soon wakes up again, calling out for his twin brother, Tommy. Billy Maximoff’s soul now resides in William Kaplan’s body.
Billy is understandably confused when he wakes up in the hospital. When he catches a glimpse of himself in a reflective window, he doesn’t recognize his own reflection.
His parents seem unfamiliar to him, and he grows upset when he hears them having a minor disagreement.
He begs them not to argue, clearly distressed. The doctors assure Billy’s parents that his memory loss will eventually fade, and he is soon cleared to be discharged from the hospital. Billy, although still confused, insists he is ready to go home.
When he arrives home, Billy’s confusion only deepens. The house feels unfamiliar, and even his dog barks at him, not recognizing him. His parents become increasingly worried as they see that Billy is struggling to understand what is happening.
Things become even more complicated when Billy realizes that he can hear their thoughts, with voices flooding his mind and overwhelming him.
After this unsettling revelation, Billy tries to act normally and heads to his room. He looks around the space, which feels foreign to him, and practices saying his new name, “William Kaplan,” in the mirror.
Fast forward three years, and we see Billy in a car with his boyfriend, Eddie (Miles Gutierrez-Riley). Eddie notices that Billy always carries around a wooden block and asks him about it.
Billy explains that it’s a sigil and compares it to a puzzle he hasn’t been able to solve. As they talk, Billy hears Eddie’s internal thoughts as he debates whether to tell Billy he loves him.
This makes Billy panic, and he pulls away from the kiss, admitting that something happened the day of the car crash. He tells Eddie that he’s not really William Kaplan and that he still can’t remember anything from before the accident.
Despite this, Billy confesses that he loves Eddie. Eddie kisses him and assures him that he’s not crazy, but is curious to know—if Billy isn’t William Kaplan, then who is he?
Billy shows Eddie all the evidence he’s gathered over the years. He has collected newspaper clippings about the hex and compiled various theories. Eddie believes that the anomaly was just a botched Avengers training exercise, but Billy thinks there’s more to it.
They watch a video by Jennifer Kale (Sasheer Zamata), then look at online footage of the hex. In the footage, Billy notices runes, which makes him suspect witchcraft is involved.
Most people from Westview refuse to talk about the anomaly, but Billy manages to connect with someone on Reddit who agrees to meet him in a parking garage.
In the parking garage, Billy and Eddie encounter a mysterious man in a trench coat lurking in the shadows. It turns out to be Ralph Bohner, but he reveals that his real name is Randall. Randall is visibly paranoid, and who wouldn’t be after what he experienced?
He remembers everything Wanda Maximoff did to him, describing it as feeling like his life was playing out on TV inside his head, but he had no control over it.
Billy asks if Randall gained any special powers from the experience, but Randall acts as though Billy is being ridiculous.
Despite his outward denial, Billy can hear Randall mentally begging him not to ask about Agatha, which, of course, prompts Billy to do exactly that.
Randall agrees to tell Billy everything he knows, but only if they give him cash or promise to attend his one-man show. It’s hard not to admire his persistence.
Randall reveals that his experience was even worse than most of the other people in Westview.
Agatha manipulated him like a puppet, forcing him to play her husband. On top of that, she stole his house, completely ruining its market value, and kept his Blu-ray collection!
Randall also reveals that Agatha made him act like a bad influence on Wanda’s kids and even poisoned a dog.
When Billy asks about the children, Randall says they disappeared, but he assumes they were probably absorbed into the red bubble along with everything else Wanda created.
Randall is still traumatized and refuses to face Agatha again. He tells Billy that Agatha is still living in Westview but warns him against going after her. According to Randall, Agatha is far more dangerous than Billy realizes.
Ignoring Randall’s warning, Billy becomes determined to learn more about Agatha. He listens to Lorna’s version of the ballad as he goes over the notes he took during their conversation. Billy searches for information about Agatha online, finding a website called Brujapedia, where he reads about her past.
He discovers that Agatha is the only known survivor of the Witches’ Road. Believing that this could hold the key to unlocking his missing memories, Billy decides to head to Westview to confront Agatha.
When Billy arrives at Agatha’s house, he stands in front of Wanda’s old home, feeling conflicted. He checks his spellbook for a release spell, which says he will need a personal item of significance. He sends Eddie a heartfelt text message before sneaking into Agatha’s house. Inside, he finds her brooch, but in the process, he accidentally knocks over a lamp.
Agatha catches him, and the episode shows the scene from her point of view. She initially thinks Billy is there to hurt her, but after some interrogation, she realizes the truth. She admits that she suspected who Billy was from the moment they first met, but now it’s confirmed—Billy Maximoff is back.
In a powerful moment, Agatha explains that all witches with beating hearts can sense Billy’s presence. She assures him that there’s no need to feel guilty about his abilities.
Agatha tells Billy that breaking the rules is what kept him alive, making him special and powerful. However, Billy tells her that he doesn’t need her anymore. Right then, his powers stop working, and Agatha mocks him for being unable to control them without her help.
The episode wraps up with Agatha pushing Billy to confront his desires. She taunts him, asking what he truly wants at the end of his journey. It’s not Wanda, since she chose to stay with strangers instead of him. It’s not Vision, since no one knows where he is.
Billy realizes that his true motivation is finding Tommy, and he admits that he can sense Tommy’s presence but can’t seem to locate him. Agatha suggests they continue their journey together, but Billy makes it clear that he doesn’t trust her. Agatha laughs it off, calling their situation a race and inviting Billy to join her for the next trial.
This episode takes viewers through a rollercoaster of emotions, with many complex relationships and supernatural twists along the way. Let’s break it all down.
We begin at William Kaplan’s bar mitzvah, where the program reveals that Teen (played by Joe Locke) is actually named William Kaplan. The event itself is a beautiful celebration of love, surrounded by family and a supportive community. His parents and the entire party show him immense love, which sets the tone for his upbringing.
It’s also worth noting the creative touch from the production team, as the centerpieces resemble the trees seen on the Witches’ Road. It’s a subtle, yet impressive design that adds more depth to the atmosphere.
Patti LuPone’s character, Lilia, appears at the bar mitzvah in a fortune-telling tent, offering William an unexpected reading. She tells him that he has a long journey ahead, filled with transformation. However, the mood changes when she sees his lifeline split in two as the lights flicker.
While Lilia reassures him that it could mean various things, William becomes understandably nervous. In a touching moment, Lilia tells William he’s a good person and reminds him to focus on enjoying the present, since that’s all he can truly count on.
As William leaves, Lilia draws a sigil on a block of wood and slips it into his coat pocket, later forgetting she even did it.
William’s father interrupts the celebration to warn everyone about an issue in Westview, and they rush home. On the way, William notices the sigil and catches sight of a red light from the hex. His mother, distracted by the light, crashes their car into a tree.
William’s parents immediately call the police, but it’s too late for him. Bleeding heavily in the backseat, William dies, only to wake up moments later, calling for Tommy. Billy Maximoff’s soul now inhabits William Kaplan’s body.
This shift leaves Billy confused as he recovers in the hospital. When he looks in a reflective window, he realizes he doesn’t recognize his parents or even himself. The doctors explain that his amnesia will fade with time, and soon, he is ready to go home. But as Billy steps into the unfamiliar house, things take an even stranger turn.
His dog barks at him, not recognizing him, and Billy begins hearing his parents’ thoughts, which overwhelm him. He tries to act normal, but the loud voices in his head make it difficult. He later practices in the mirror, repeating to himself that he’s William Kaplan.
Three years later, we see Billy with his boyfriend, Eddie (played by Miles Gutierrez-Riley). Eddie notices that Billy always carries around a wooden block and asks about it. Billy explains that it’s a sigil, a puzzle he hasn’t yet solved. When Billy overhears Eddie debating whether or not to tell him “I love you,” it sends him into a panic.
Billy pulls away from their kiss and confesses what happened on the day of the car crash. He admits he’s not really William Kaplan and still can’t remember anything about his life before the accident.
After sharing this truth, Billy tells Eddie he loves him, and Eddie responds with a kiss. Though Eddie doesn’t believe Billy is crazy, he does want to know one thing: if Billy isn’t William Kaplan, then who is he?
Billy then shares the evidence he’s collected, including newspaper reports on the hex. Eddie, ever the optimist, believes the anomaly was just an Avengers training exercise gone wrong. But Billy, more skeptical, insists there’s more to the story.
Together, they watch a video of Jennifer Kale (Sasheer Zamata) discussing the event. While reviewing footage of the anomaly online, Billy spots some runes, which lead him to suspect witchcraft was involved. Though most of the townspeople of Westview refuse to talk about it, Billy connects with someone on Reddit who agrees to meet him in a parking garage.
The meeting takes place in a dimly lit parking garage, where a man in a trench coat emerges from the shadows. He turns out to be Ralph Bohner, though he now reveals his real name is Randall. Randall, visibly paranoid, recalls the traumatic experience he endured under Wanda Maximoff’s control. He describes it as living inside a TV show that he couldn’t turn off.
When Billy asks if he gained any special powers from the hex, Randall dismisses the idea. However, Billy hears Randall’s internal thoughts begging him not to ask about Agatha Harkness, which naturally leads Billy to inquire further.
In exchange for cash or attendance at his one-man show, Randall agrees to tell Billy everything. He reveals how Agatha manipulated him into playing the role of her fake husband, ruining his life.
Not only did she take over his house and destroy its value, but she also kept his entire Blu-ray collection! More seriously, Agatha forced him to act as a negative influence on Wanda’s children and even poisoned a dog.
Randall doesn’t know what happened to the children, but he believes they were likely absorbed into the red bubble along with everything else Wanda created. Though traumatized, Randall warns Billy not to seek out Agatha, claiming she’s far more dangerous than he can imagine.
Ignoring Randall’s advice, Billy goes home and immediately starts researching Agatha. He listens to Lorna’s version of the ballad while going through his notes.
He searches “Agatha Harkness ancient witch” online, finding a photograph of her and additional information about her history on “Brujapedia,” a hilarious witch-themed encyclopedia. Billy soon realizes that the Witches’ Road could hold the key to what he’s been searching for and sets off for Agatha’s house in Westview.
Arriving in Westview, Billy takes a moment to reflect on Wanda’s old home before checking his spellbook for a release spell. The book informs him that he needs a personal item to complete the spell. He sends Eddie affectionate text messages before sneaking into Agatha’s house to retrieve her brooch.
In the process, Billy accidentally knocks over a lamp and climbs out the window, only to be caught by Agatha. The chase that follows is far less dramatic than in Agatha’s version of events, and Billy, ever the kind soul, even offers to help her when she falls.
The interrogation happens in Agatha’s living room, where she’s dressed in a Bohner Family Reunion shirt and wielding a garden hose nozzle gun. Billy accuses Agatha of typecasting him as the guilty teen, but he swears that’s not the case.
He attempts to cast the release spell, but Agatha brings out duct tape. When the spell doesn’t work as planned, she mocks him, telling him he’s still William Kaplan. Agatha reminds Billy that, despite his protests, he has more in common with her than he thinks.
Back on the Witches’ Road, Agatha crawls out of the mud, exhausted and struggling, only to throw off her jacket in frustration. She confronts Billy, who now holds the crushed sigil block in his hand.
Agatha sarcastically praises his debut, accusing him of lying about not understanding sigils or wanting power. Though Billy denies it, Agatha is unconvinced. She claims to have suspected his true identity when they first met, noting that he shares the same telltale signs as Wanda.
In a surprising turn, Agatha reassures Billy that he shouldn’t feel guilty for breaking the rules. She reminds him that witches have survived for centuries by bending the rules, and that his talent makes him special. Billy, however, insists he doesn’t need Agatha’s help.
Yet, as his powers begin to falter, Agatha taunts him, questioning how he’ll finish what he started without control over his abilities. She then challenges him, claiming that what Billy truly seeks isn’t Wanda or Vision, but his twin brother, Tommy.
The episode ends with Agatha inviting Billy to continue their journey together, despite his mistrust of her. With only a few episodes left in the season, the tension between these two characters promises an explosive conclusion to the series.
Episode 6 of Agatha All Along masterfully weaves together emotional depth, supernatural intrigue, and character development.
The return of Ralph Bohner, now revealed as Randall, adds a layer of trauma to the already complex storylines, especially with Agatha’s manipulations coming to light.
Billy’s journey of self-discovery intensifies as he begins to unravel the truth about his identity, leading to a poignant confrontation with Agatha.
This episode brilliantly showcases the show’s ability to balance heartfelt moments—such as Billy’s bar mitzvah and his relationship with Eddie—with darker themes of control, trauma, and power. The development of Billy’s character from a confused soul to someone determined to face his past promises even more twists ahead.
As the season approaches its climax, viewers are left eagerly anticipating how Billy and Agatha’s complex relationship will grow and whether Billy will finally reunite with his twin brother, Tommy, while mastering his extraordinary powers. Tune in to Disney+ to watch the upcoming episodes.
