TWICE member Nayeon has become the subject of online controversy following a surprise collaboration with American singer-songwriter Charlie Puth.
The idol joined Puth onstage during his concert in South Korea, where the two performed a duet of his hit song “We Don’t Talk Anymore.”
Although the performance showcased an unexpected musical pairing, it also triggered criticism from some fans over Puth’s past controversies.
Videos of the collaboration circulated on social media on October 11, 2026, drawing mixed reactions from listeners.
While some viewers appreciated the opportunity to see Nayeon perform alongside an international artist, others expressed disappointment over her association with Puth.
The discussion quickly expanded beyond the performance itself, with fans debating the singer’s public reputation and questioning whether further collaborations involving TWICE should take place.
Nayeon’s Surprise Duet With Charlie Puth Sparks Fan Reactions
Nayeon’s appearance at Charlie Puth’s concert surprised fans, particularly those who had been following speculation about a possible collaboration between the singer and TWICE.
The pair performed “We Don’t Talk Anymore,” Puth’s popular song featuring Selena Gomez. Clips from the stage circulated widely online, giving fans a glimpse of Nayeon singing the track alongside its original male vocalist.
However, the performance soon became controversial among sections of the TWICE fandom.
Some fans said they were disappointed by the collaboration and hoped it would remain a one-time event.
Others questioned the decision to associate the group with Puth, arguing that his past public controversies made the appearance uncomfortable for them.
The backlash was not limited to concerns about the collaboration.
Nayeon’s vocals also became a subject of online discussion, with some social media users criticizing her delivery and comparing her rendition with Selena Gomez’s original recording.
These reactions reflected divided opinions about the performance.
While some comments focused on Nayeon’s singing, others concentrated primarily on the broader controversy surrounding Puth.
As clips continued circulating, the discussion grew into a debate about artistic collaborations, celebrity reputations, and the expectations fans place on K-pop idols.
Charlie Puth’s Past Controversies Fuel the Backlash
Much of the criticism surrounding the duet stemmed from previous public allegations and disputes involving Charlie Puth.
In June 2025, Jade Thirlwall, formerly of Little Mix, reportedly identified Puth as someone she would refuse to collaborate with during a radio appearance.
Although she did not elaborate fully on her reasons, speculation about their past interactions circulated online.
The following month, actress and singer Bella Thorne publicly criticized Puth, accusing him of making false statements about her and contributing to online hostility after she declined his advances.
These claims became part of the broader discussion surrounding his public image.
Puth has also faced criticism over his social media activity following the October 7 attacks, with some online users labeling him a Zionist.
His views and perceived political associations have consequently become another point of contention among sections of K-pop fandoms.
These controversies have influenced how some fans respond to artists working with him.
As a result, Nayeon’s appearance with Puth prompted calls for TWICE and its agency, JYP Entertainment, to avoid further association with the singer.
Nevertheless, the criticism represents reactions expressed by some social media users and should not be taken as a reflection of every fan’s opinion.
The duet itself was a live performance, and no official announcement confirming a separate collaboration between Nayeon and Puth has been reported in the article.
For now, the unexpected stage pairing has placed Nayeon at the center of a wider online discussion about celebrity collaborations and accountability.
Whether the performance leads to any future musical partnership remains unclear, but the mixed response demonstrates how quickly an apparently celebratory moment can become controversial within the K-pop community.
