Over 800 officials from the United States and Europe have jointly criticized Western policies toward Israel and Gaza, expressing concerns of potential complicity in war crimes. The statement accuses governments of a “plausible risk” of contributing to grave violations of international humanitarian law, war crimes, and even ethnic cleansing or genocide.
Among the signatories are approximately 80 U.S. officials and diplomats. The coordinated dissent, a rare occurrence, calls for governments to use their leverage to secure a ceasefire and challenges the rationale behind the Israeli operation.
The public letter follows the International Court of Justice (ICJ) finding South Africa’s claim of Israeli genocide in Gaza “plausible” and ordering measures to limit destruction and ensure humanitarian aid access.
The signatories, who coordinated the letter across European Union institutions and U.S. civil servants, highlight their shared concern about being ignored by their governments.
They stress the inadequacy of current talking points and argue for dissenting voices when internal concerns are disregarded. While the letter does not list its signatories, a U.S. official noted many colleagues feared job loss, reflecting stronger protections for dissent in Europe.
The officials contend that raising internal concerns has often been overruled by political and ideological considerations. The letter emphasizes the officials’ obligation to prevent complicity in a significant human catastrophe. They criticize Israel’s military operations as counterproductive to its national security goals, strengthening the appeal of negative actors.
The officials argue that unconditional Western support for Israel weakens moral standing, undermines global efforts for freedom and justice, and hampers responses to Russia, China, and Iran. They call on governments to develop a strategy for lasting peace, ensuring a secure Palestinian state and Israel’s security, to prevent future attacks and offensives in Gaza.
