Fullmetal Alchemist: Brotherhood is one of the most beloved anime series of all time. Its carefully crafted story, deep characters, and satisfying ending have left a lasting impression on fans worldwide. However, not many people know that the ending of the series could have turned out very differently. Let’s take a closer look at how the story almost took an alternate path and what that would have meant for the series.
At its core, Fullmetal Alchemist: Brotherhood is a story about the Elric brothers, Edward and Alphonse, and their journey to regain what they lost after attempting forbidden alchemy. Their goal to restore Alphonse’s body and Edward’s arm and leg leads them on a dangerous path, filled with battles, friendships, and moral dilemmas.
The series ends on a hopeful note. After defeating Father and the Homunculi, Edward sacrifices his ability to perform alchemy to bring Alphonse back to life. This decision symbolizes the themes of sacrifice, growth, and the value of human connection. Fans praised this ending for wrapping up the story in a way that felt both emotional and complete.
Before the anime aired, Hiromu Arakawa, the creator of the Fullmetal Alchemist manga, considered a different conclusion. Early drafts of the story explored a darker and more tragic ending. In one version, Edward and Alphonse would have been unable to reclaim their original bodies. Instead, they would accept their fates, choosing to live with the consequences of their actions rather than continue their pursuit of a solution.
Another concept involved Edward making a permanent and devastating sacrifice—his life—for Alphonse’s. While this ending would have underscored the themes of selflessness and love, it would have left fans heartbroken, as the brothers would not have been able to live their lives together after their long and arduous journey.
Arakawa ultimately decided on a more hopeful ending to reflect the growth and resilience of the characters. She wanted the story to leave viewers with a sense of closure and optimism. After everything Edward and Alphonse endured, they deserved to find peace and happiness. The chosen ending allows the brothers to fulfill their dreams, and it emphasizes the importance of moving forward, even after loss.
Additionally, the hopeful conclusion aligns with the story’s message that human strength and determination can overcome even the greatest challenges. It’s a testament to the bonds of family, friendship, and perseverance.
The ending of Fullmetal Alchemist: Brotherhood is one of the reasons why the series remains so highly regarded. Fans admire how it ties up the story’s themes and delivers a satisfying conclusion without feeling rushed or incomplete. Knowing that a darker ending was once considered makes the final outcome even more meaningful.
While the alternate endings would have taken the series in a different direction, the chosen conclusion perfectly captures the spirit of the story. It ensures that Edward and Alphonse’s journey is remembered as one of hope, sacrifice, and redemption—a legacy that continues to inspire fans around the world.
