Paramount+ has just dropped what many are calling Taylor Sheridan’s best TV episode ever, and it’s not from Yellowstone or Landman. The honor goes to Mayor of Kingstown, a show that has quietly built a loyal fanbase since its debut.
Season 4, Episode 9, titled “Teeth and Tissue,” has set a new record with a 9.5 rating on IMDb, surpassing even the acclaimed finale of 1923. This achievement is especially notable given that the episode serves as the penultimate chapter of an already exceptional season, which itself has a perfect 100% score on Rotten Tomatoes.
Sheridan’s influence on streaming TV is undeniable. He currently has four of the top five series trending worldwide on Paramount+, and his latest release has only solidified his reputation as a master of gritty, morally complex drama.
The fact that this record-breaking episode comes from Mayor of Kingstown, a series often overshadowed by Yellowstone, shows that Sheridan’s creative range extends far beyond Westerns and oil fields.
Also Read: Band of Brothers Episode 9, Why We Fight Is Both Its Best and Hardest to Watch
Mayor of Kingstown’s rise to the top spot among Sheridan’s works is a testament to the show’s evolving storytelling and character depth. Season 4 has been praised for its relentless pacing, nuanced exploration of corruption, and the emotional toll it takes on its characters.
Episode 9, in particular, has been hailed as a turning point, with critics and fans alike agreeing that it sets a new benchmark for television crime drama.
What Makes “Teeth and Tissue” So Special
The acclaim for Episode 9 is not just about numbers. Fans and critics agree that the episode delivers a powerful blend of storytelling, character development, and suspense. The narrative centers on Mike McLusky, played by Jeremy Renner, as he faces some of his toughest challenges yet.
The stakes are higher than ever, and the episode is packed with unexpected twists that keep viewers on the edge of their seats.
The episode is praised for its intricate plotting and emotional depth. Mike’s journey in this chapter is a study in moral compromise and personal collapse.
The show explores how the pressures of Kingstown, its corruption, violence, and relentless cycles of revenge can push even the most principled individuals to their limits. The cinematography and musical score add to the tension, creating a mood that is both haunting and immersive.

Several standout moments in the episode have sparked intense discussion among fans. The prison massacre, Mike’s manipulation of Frank Moses, and the shocking diner ambush are all cited as highlights that showcase Sheridan’s skill at building suspense and delivering emotional payoffs.
The prison scene is particularly memorable, as it sets the stage for a dramatic confrontation that leaves lasting consequences for the entire city. Mike’s decision to use Frank as a pawn in his larger scheme reveals the depth of his desperation and the lengths he’s willing to go to protect his family.
The episode’s final scenes set up a dramatic finale, leaving audiences eager for the next installment. The tension between Mike and his brother Mitch, the shifting alliances among the city’s power players, and the looming threat of federal intervention all contribute to a sense of urgency that permeates the episode.
The way Sheridan weaves these threads together is a masterclass in serialized storytelling, and it’s clear that every detail has been carefully crafted to maximize impact.
The Impact on Streaming and Sheridan’s Legacy
The success of Mayor of Kingstown Season 4 Episode 9 has broader implications for the streaming industry. It demonstrates that audiences are hungry for complex, character-driven crime dramas, not just flashy action or broad humor.
Sheridan’s ability to craft stories that resonate with viewers, regardless of genre, is a testament to his talent and vision.
Despite the episode’s critical acclaim, Paramount+ has not yet confirmed a fifth season of Mayor of Kingstown. This uncertainty has only heightened anticipation among fans, who are hoping that the show’s record-breaking performance will secure its future.
Sheridan’s other projects, including Yellowstone and Tulsa King, continue to dominate streaming charts, but Mayor of Kingstown’s latest episode proves that there is still room for surprises in his TV universe.
Sheridan’s legacy as a storyteller is growing stronger with each new release. His work on Mayor of Kingstown, particularly in Season 4, Episode 9, sets a new standard for TV crime drama.
The episode’s record-breaking rating and widespread praise are well-deserved, and they ensure that Mayor of Kingstown will be remembered as one of Sheridan’s finest achievements.
Also Read: Fox’s Midseason Sensation, Best Medicine Is A Bold Remake Of Doc Martin

























