The NFL Players Association (NFLPA) is expressing opposition to the potential implementation of penalties for the “hip-drop” tackle, which is among the proposals set to be voted on by NFL owners during the upcoming annual league meeting.
The “hip-drop” tackle has drawn attention due to concerns about its impact on player safety. NFL executive Jeff Miller previously stated that such tackles could increase the risk of injury by 25%, prompting the league to consider outlawing them.
However, the NFLPA is urging the league to reconsider its stance, citing potential confusion among players, coaches, officials, and fans if the rule were to be implemented. The association emphasizes its commitment to improving the game while prioritizing health and safety but asserts that it cannot support a rule change that may lead to ambiguity and disruption.
The prevalence of the “hip-drop” tackle has reportedly increased in response to rules aimed at reducing concussions. Defenders have adapted their tackling techniques to target the midsection rather than making contact at higher points, aiming to wrap up opponents to mitigate head injuries.
Despite a decline in concussions over the past decade, lower extremity strains have emerged as a significant injury concern in the NFL, with the NFLPA highlighting a recent decrease in such injuries in 2023 as evidence of progress in player safety.
As the league and players’ union takes note of the discussions surrounding player safety initiatives, the stance of the NFLPA underscores the importance of considering the broader implications and potential consequences of proposed rule changes on all stakeholders involved in the game.
Ravens tight end Mark Andrews was among the notable players who sustained a serious injury due to a “hip-drop” tackle during the 2023 season. His absence from Baltimore’s final six games followed a tackle by Bengals linebacker Logan Wilson.
Andrews refrained from expressing any opinions on the tackle and its potential prohibition. However, his teammate at the time, Patrick Queen, vehemently opposed outlawing the tackle.
“I hate that Mark is hurt. Prayers for him,” Queen expressed. “But at the end of the day, we play football. We play a tackling sport. I don’t think a hip drop tackle is that bad of a thing. How else do you want us to tackle? Just let the guy run past you?”
The focus of the league this offseason appears to be on eliminating the “hip-drop” tackle and finding ways to enhance kickoffs without compromising safety. Any proposed rule change must garner at least 75% approval from the league’s owners.
