When “Nuremberg,” starring Russell Crowe as Nazi war criminal Hermann Göring, premiered at the Toronto International Film Festival in September 2025, it met a lukewarm response from critics.
The film initially received a disappointing Rotten Tomatoes score hovering around 40 to 45 percent, marking it as “Rotten” by the site’s standards.
This tepid reception stemmed largely from critiques of inconsistent tone and storytelling, with some reviewers describing the movie as unclear in its messaging and pacing. For example, a ScreenRant review rated it low, highlighting a lost tone and narrative challenges.
Yet, unlike typical new releases that often experience their scores dropping as harsher reviews accumulate, “Nuremberg” did the opposite. Over the following weeks, the Rotten Tomatoes score climbed dramatically to its current rating of 67 percent, an increase of more than 20 points.
Such an upward movement is almost unprecedented and suggests increasing appreciation for the film’s merits. Many new critics praised the outstanding performances, particularly Crowe’s embodiment of Göring, and the gripping depiction of the psychological warfare within the trials.
Also read: Superman Streaming Surge Shakes Up Netflix’s Top Movie Rankings
The film’s rising score signals a shift in critical consensus that may position it more favorably for audiences and awards consideration. This phenomenon was covered extensively by outlets such as Collider and FandomWire, which emphasized the rarity and significance of the trend.
Courtroom Drama Highlights War Crime Trials and Moral Complexities
“Nuremberg” centers on the intense psychological interrogation conducted by American psychiatrist Douglas Kelley, portrayed by Rami Malek, alongside Crowe’s portrayal of Göring facing judgment for his war crimes.
The story focuses on the intricate mental battle between interrogator and defendant as Kelley assesses the Nazis’ mental fitness for trial, weaving in perspectives on justice, morality, and the legacy of evil.
Critically, the movie explores the tension between legal formalities and the humanity of those caught in history’s darkest chapters.
Several reviews, including those from The Hollywood Reporter and The Wrap, noted the film’s weighty atmosphere and important themes, complimenting the compelling ensemble cast, with Michael Shannon also highlighted.
Viewers and critics alike have remarked on its powerful score and the palpable tension that fills the courtroom scenes.
Despite some critiques regarding historical focus and casting choices, such as the lack of German actors for German roles, crowd reactions at screenings were notably engaged, underscoring the film’s emotional impact.
As the film approaches its scheduled November 7 theatrical release, anticipation builds not just for its commercial performance but for potential recognition in the awards season.
Industry insiders point to the film’s critical turnaround, asserting that climbing above the 60 percent mark solidifies it as a contender, raising Crowe’s chances for Best Lead Actor nominations and generating more Oscar chatter.
Oscar Buzz Intensifies with Rising Critical Favor and Strategic Releases
Sony Pictures appears to be positioning “Nuremberg” carefully for awards consideration, treating the film as a serious contender. The studio reportedly plans to campaign aggressively for Russell Crowe’s performance and Rami Malek’s role in the supporting cast.
The improved critical reception helps in this endeavor, as Academy voters often consider the wider field of reviews before endorsing films. The shift closer to a “Certified Fresh” rating on Rotten Tomatoes, a milestone the movie edges nearer to with each new positive review, further benefits the campaign.
Beyond the awards implications, the film’s release in major international markets, including India, a key territory for Hollywood prestige releases, is seen as an important factor in boosting box office returns and critical momentum.
“Nuremberg” represents a distinctive blend of historical drama with psychological thriller elements, a combination that has gained traction in recent years among cinephiles and industry observers.
Such momentum after an initially disappointing start is uncommon but not without precedent. It highlights how complex films directed at mature, thoughtful audiences can find their footing over time rather than immediately dominating early reviews.
The emerging reputation of “Nuremberg” suggests it may stimulate renewed interest in WWII narratives that confront uncomfortable truths with nuance and strong performances.
References and further reading for this evolving cinematic story include review compilations from Rotten Tomatoes, news and analysis articles from Collider and ScreenRant, and festival coverage from reputable film news sources like The Hollywood Reporter and FandomWire, all confirming the film’s unique journey on the critical spectrum and the factors driving its newfound acclaim.
This transformation from a shaky start to growing admiration makes Russell Crowe’s “Nuremberg” worth watching for audiences interested in history, legal drama, and award-worthy performances.
Also read: Gwyneth Paltrow Hints Marvel Return Sparks Excitement Among Fans
