Mothers’ Instinct is a gripping psychological thriller that tells the story of two mothers, Celine (played by Anne Hathaway) and Alice (played by Jessica Chastain). This film is set in the 1960s. At first, Celine and Alice appear to live perfect suburban lives in America.
However, their lives take a dark turn when Celine’s son, Max (Baylen D. Bielitz), dies after falling from a roof. This tragedy triggers a series of events filled with paranoia, deceit, and ultimately murder. Celine ends up killing her husband, Damian (Josh Charles), and Alice and her husband, Simon (Anders Danielsen Lie), adopt Celine’s son, Theo (Eamon Patrick O’Connell).
Benoît Delhomme makes his directorial debut with Mothers’ Instinct. He uses the tools available to him very effectively. The costumes and cinematography bring life to the story. Delhomme had just 24 days to shoot the film, but he made the most of this time.
The film is not just about the story; it also discusses important themes. Anne Hathaway and Jessica Chastain deliver remarkable performances in Mothers’ Instinct. Their acting and the thoughtful writing create a deep commentary on sexism from the past, showing that many of these issues still exist today.
Jessica Chastain and Anne Hathaway Shine in ‘Mothers’ Instinct’
It might seem obvious to say that Chastain and Hathaway give amazing performances. However, it is true that they are the stars of Mothers’ Instinct. Both actresses spoke to Glamour Magazine about their experiences while making the film.
Chastain shared that they felt “safe” with each other, even though their characters were engaged in their own Cold War. The final fight scene between Chastain and Hathaway has a raw, intense energy as both mothers struggle for the right to be Theo’s mother.
The trust they had in each other greatly influenced this scene. Hathaway felt “safe enough to be violent towards someone,” describing the moment as “really something.”
The actresses show their differences while also demonstrating why they might be friends. This showcases their great talent in Mothers’ Instinct. In one scene at the beginning, Chastain’s character, Alice, and Hathaway’s character, Celine, talk about their desires in life.
Even though they do not say exactly what they are thinking, it becomes clear that Alice wants more than just being a homemaker, while Celine seems content with her role.
This discussion sets up the conflict between these women. Celine desperately wants to be a mother, but she might also feel jealous of Alice’s ambitions for more in life. Meanwhile, Alice might feel envious of Celine’s natural motherly instincts since she was too afraid to hold her baby after Theo’s birth.
The contrast between these two characters keeps viewers on the edge of their seats during every scene they share. Each actress brings layers to their performance, keeping the audience guessing about their true feelings.
Fantastic Filmmaking Makes ‘Mothers’ Instinct’ a Beautiful Film to Watch
The practical aspects of filmmaking come together beautifully in Mothers’ Instinct, making it visually stunning and complementing the performances of the actresses. As a period piece set in the 1960s, the film looks authentic, thanks to the wonderful costumes designed by Mitchell Travis.
He told Revamp Magazine that there was a strong focus on the two main characters’ wardrobes. Celine wears traditional clothes that are “quiet, still, and reserved.”
In contrast, Alice wears more “independent” and expressive clothes that reflect her “energy and movement.” The use of costumes helps viewers track how the relationship between the characters changes, adding depth to the tension that simmers beneath the surface.
The cinematography is another essential element that enhances the film’s visual appeal. The opening shots, such as the ambulance in the grass, immediately indicate that something is wrong.
The image of a toy left behind by a child symbolizes the loss of safety for children. This feeling of neglect is evident in Max’s death and how Alice and Celine push Theo to his limits as their paranoia takes over.
One chilling moment occurs when Celine eerily cradles Max’s body. This scene heightens the film’s brutality and horror. Celine’s shocked expression as blood runs down her fingers adds to the disturbing nature of the moment.
This visual portrayal recalls Jackie Kennedy cradling her husband, John F. Kennedy, after his assassination, highlighting the tragic comparison between their experiences.
Delhomme explained in an interview with A Rabbit’s Foot that this scene is his favorite because the camera “stays in the detail,” forcing the audience to witness the harsh reality of what has just happened, just as Celine must.
‘Mothers’ Instinct’ Shows Both Past and Present Sexism
Mothers’ Instinct also offers a thought-provoking scheme of the sexism that women faced in the 1950s and 1960s. The film shows how these societal expectations pushed women into certain roles and how these issues still resonate today.
According to Anne Hathaway, Celine is given “prescribed identities” that she struggles against. These identities include being a mother and the grieving mother who lost her child. It is fascinating to see how Celine fights against one of these identities only to fit into another. She believes she is worthless if she is not a mother.
Celine experiences a forced hysterectomy, as Hathaway explains. She is put to sleep and has her uterus removed during childbirth. This experience creates a “rage that would be under a really pretty surface.”
Many people can relate this situation to the current issue of abortion bans, which Hathaway notes is “important to me.” This reflects how some people try to control women’s bodies through invasive actions.
On the other hand, Alice faces cruelty from her husband, Simon, when she wants to return to journalism. She desires more from her life beyond being a wife and mother.
When Simon suggests she write “something for the school newspaper,” the expression on Alice’s face is heartbreaking. This moment underscores the unfair power dynamics of the time. Simon only wants Alice to fulfill the roles of a wife and mother. He disregards her instincts about danger later in the story.
Themes of Motherhood and Identity
Mothers’ Instinct also shows deep themes of motherhood and identity. The film asks the audience to consider what it means to be a mother and how societal pressures shape that identity. Celine’s desperate need to be a mother drives her actions, leading her down a dark path.
She believes her worth is tied to her ability to care for her child. When tragedy strikes, her identity shatters. This prompts her to take extreme measures to regain a sense of control.
Alice’s struggle with motherhood is different yet equally significant. She feels confined to her role as a mother and yearns for more. Her ambitions clash with the expectations placed on her, causing tension in her marriage. This conflict illustrates the difficulty women face in balancing personal desires with societal demands.
The film effectively highlights the struggle many women experience when their identities are defined by motherhood alone.
The dynamic between Celine and Alice also adds depth to the theme of friendship. While they are friends, their relationship is fraught with tension and competition.
Celine’s jealousy of Alice’s ambition creates conflict, and Alice’s fear of Celine’s maternal instincts complicates their bond. This complexity makes their relationship feel authentic and relatable, showcasing the multifaceted nature of female friendships.
The Visual Storytelling
The visual storytelling in Mothers’ Instinct plays a crucial role in conveying the film’s themes and emotions. The cinematography captures the subtleties of the characters’ experiences.
For instance, the use of light and shadow emphasizes the mood of each scene, often reflecting the characters’ internal struggles. The contrast between light and dark imagery symbolizes the conflict between their desires and societal expectations.
The film’s production design also contributes to its storytelling. The settings are carefully crafted to reflect the time period, immersing the audience in the 1960s suburban life.
The attention to detail in the homes, cars, and props enhances the authenticity of the story. This careful craftsmanship allows viewers to feel the tension and unease that permeates the characters’ lives.
Furthermore, the sound design adds another layer to the film’s atmosphere. The use of music and ambient sounds heightens the emotional impact of key scenes.
The score complements the tension and drama, drawing the audience deeper into the story. By combining visual and auditory elements, Mothers’ Instinct creates a rich cinematic experience that resonates with viewers.
A Film Worth Watching
Mothers’ Instinct is a film I highly recommend you watch immediately. It is surprising how quickly it draws you in, keeping you on the edge of your seat. Each line of dialogue and each expression is brilliantly portrayed by Jessica Chastain and Anne Hathaway.
The film is visually stunning, with every shot carefully crafted to serve a purpose. The combination of excellent acting, thoughtful writing, and beautiful cinematography creates a compelling narrative that shows complex themes of motherhood and sexism.
The film leaves viewers questioning their trust in the people they love most, especially regarding the safety of their children. The story’s twists and turns will keep you guessing, making it a truly engaging experience. Mothers’ Instinct effectively addresses important social issues while delivering a thrilling story filled with suspense and emotional depth.
Final Thoughts
Mothers’ Instinct is a psychological thriller set in the 1960s, following two mothers, Celine (Anne Hathaway) and Alice (Jessica Chastain), who seem to have perfect suburban lives until tragedy strikes. Celine’s son, Max, dies after falling from a roof, leading to a chain of paranoia, deceit, and ultimately murder.
Celine kills her husband, Damian, and Alice adopts her son, Theo. The film shows themes of motherhood, identity, and sexism, showcasing the actresses’ powerful performances.
Directed by Benoît Delhomme, it combines stunning visuals and an engaging narrative, making it a compelling reflection on the struggles women face in society.
Mothers’ Instinct is more than just a thriller; it is a reflection on the challenges women face in their pursuit of identity and fulfillment.
The performances by Anne Hathaway and Jessica Chastain upgrade the film, making it a memorable viewing experience. The film captures the complexities of female relationships and the societal pressures that shape women’s lives.
As you watch Mothers’ Instinct, you will find yourself reflecting on the themes of motherhood, identity, and the lingering impact of sexism. This film is a powerful reminder of the struggles women have faced in the past and continue to face today. It offers valuable insights into the ongoing conversation about women’s rights and societal expectations.
Whether you are drawn to psychological thrillers or are interested in the scheme of gender issues, Mothers’ Instinct is a film that delivers on all fronts. It is a beautifully crafted story that will resonate with viewers long after the credits roll.
