Amber Borzotra has captured hearts both on and off reality television screens, transforming from a Big Brother contestant to a Challenge champion while a fascinating romantic journey. The 36-year-old model and reality TV star has experienced her share of televised romances, heartbreak, and ultimately found lasting love that led to motherhood. Her dating timeline reveals a compelling story of growth, self-discovery, and the pursuit of genuine connection in the spotlight of reality television.
Born in Germany but raised in Knoxville, Tennessee, Amber first gained national attention as a contestant on Big Brother season 16 in 2014. Her striking beauty and authentic personality quickly made her a fan favorite, though her romantic entanglements on the show would prove to be just the beginning of her public love life. From her early encounters in the Big Brother house to her current relationship status as a devoted mother and partner, Amber’s romantic journey reflects the complexities of finding love while living life in the public eye.
The reality star’s transition from Big Brother to The Challenge opened new chapters in both her career and personal life. Her impressive performance on The Challenge: Double Agents, where she secured a $900,000 victory alongside CT Tamburello, proved she was more than just a pretty face. However, it was her subsequent appearances on the show that would lead to some of her most significant romantic developments, including both heartbreak and the love story that would change her life forever.
Early Reality TV Romance: Big Brother Days
Amber’s first taste of televised romance came during her stint on Big Brother 16, where she had an encounter with fellow contestant Caleb Reynolds. This early reality TV romance set the stage for what would become a pattern of finding connections within the competitive reality television environment. While this relationship didn’t develop into anything long-term, it established Amber as someone willing to open her heart on camera, a trait that would define many of her future reality TV appearances.
The Big Brother experience taught Amber valuable lessons about relationships under constant surveillance and public scrutiny. These early experiences would prove invaluable as she transitioned to the Challenge franchise, where romantic entanglements often become central storylines that can make or break both competitions and genuine connections.
The Challenge Romance: Jeremiah White Connection
Amber’s romantic life took center stage again when she appeared on The Challenge: Spies, Lies & Allies, where she developed a showmance with rookie competitor Jeremiah White. Their connection appeared genuine and intense, with both contestants expressing optimism about continuing their relationship beyond the show. Jeremiah notably stated that despite losing the competition, “I came out with Amber so you know, that’s a win for me.”
However, the transition from reality TV romance to real-world relationship proved challenging for the pair. Amber later revealed to Entertainment Weekly that their connection didn’t survive outside the competitive environment, explaining, “We don’t speak really, we don’t talk at all.” She attributed their incompatibility to being “on two different pages when things started to get more serious,” demonstrating the maturity and self-awareness that would guide her future romantic decisions.
The end of her relationship with Jeremiah marked a turning point for Amber, who began focusing on personal growth rather than actively seeking romance. This shift in mindset would prove crucial in attracting the love that would ultimately transform her life.
Finding True Love: Chauncey Palmer Romance
Just as Amber was moving on from her Challenge romance with Jeremiah, she found unexpected love with Chauncey Palmer, a 22-year-old fitness model and personal trainer based in Los Angeles. Their relationship began organically, with Amber later reflecting, “I genuinely fell for someone when I wasn’t searching for love, I was searching for peace.”
The couple went Instagram official in August 2021, shortly after Spies, Lies & Allies began airing. Amber’s caption “Cats out of the bag” marked the beginning of their public love story, though they had been together privately while her previous Challenge romance was still playing out on television. This timing created an interesting dynamic, as viewers were watching Amber’s relationship with Jeremiah unfold while she was already happily committed to Chauncey in real life.
Chauncey demonstrated remarkable maturity and confidence about Amber’s televised romance, commenting on Challenge social media posts with supportive messages like “lmaoo I ain’t tripping that’s my wife” and “He had his fun but I’m here to stay.” This secure approach to their relationship, while Amber’s previous romance aired publicly, showed the strength of their connection and Chauncey’s understanding of reality TV dynamics.
Relationship Milestones and Growing Stronger
The couple’s relationship deepened significantly when they competed together on The Challenge: Ride or Dies in 2022. Unlike many couples who struggle under the pressure of competition, Amber and Chauncey’s partnership seemed to strengthen their bond. They consistently supported each other through the highs and lows of the season, demonstrating the solid foundation of their relationship.
In September 2022, Amber shared a heartfelt tribute celebrating their first anniversary, writing, “I literally fell in love with someone that I had no intentions of falling for and it’s honestly the most beautiful kind of love. No forcing chemistry, just pure, raw connection that is created on its own.” This reflection revealed the organic nature of their relationship and how it differed from her previous reality TV romances.
Parenthood and Current Relationship Status
The couple’s relationship reached new heights with their pregnancy announcement in January 2023. Amber shared the exciting news on Instagram with a photo showing her baby bump, captioning it “Call me mama because I’m having a baby! #BabyOnTheWay.” The announcement was met with overwhelming support from their Challenge family, with many contestants expressing their excitement and congratulations.
On May 29, 2023, Amber and Chauncey welcomed their daughter, Sunny Fox Palmer. Amber announced the birth on Instagram with a touching photo of the new family, writing, “Sunny Fox Palmer ☀️ 5- 29- 23 Welcome to the world baby girl!” The arrival of their daughter marked the culmination of their love story and the beginning of their journey as parents.
Their fellow Challenge contestants flooded social media with congratulatory messages, with Tommy Bracco writing, “STOP IT RIGHT NOW SUNNY IS PERFECT!!!!!!!! Congratulations, mommy and daddy!!!!!!!!!! Love you all!!!!” The overwhelming support from their reality TV family demonstrated how beloved the couple had become within the Challenge community.
Current Status: A Love Built to Last
As of 2025, Amber Borzotra and Chauncey Palmer continue to thrive as a couple and as parents to their daughter, Sunny. Their relationship represents a successful transition from reality TV romance to real-world commitment, something that proves challenging for many couples who meet in competitive environments.
Amber’s journey from her early Big Brother days through various Challenge romances to finding lasting love with Chauncey illustrates personal growth and the importance of timing in relationships. Her current happiness as a mother and partner shows that sometimes the best love stories happen when you’re not actively searching for them, but rather focusing on becoming the best version of yourself.
