The year is 1970. The counterculture is cracking, protest signs flood the streets, and the Vietnam War burns in the background of American life. In The Mastermind, Kelly Reichardt seizes this setting not for adrenaline but for reflection. For JB Mooney, played by Josh O’Connor, neutrality is his rebellion.
Surrounded by a generation of voices demanding change, he chooses inaction, plotting a museum theft as a distraction rather than a mission.
Adapted loosely from the 1972 Worcester Art Museum robbery, the film trades genre thrills for philosophical unease. JB, a designer sleepwalking through family life in Massachusetts, dreams up a crime half-heartedly. He recruits three small-time partners with minimal conviction.
The audience senses it from the start: this theft won’t end well, not because of the law but because of moral inertia. Reichardt treats JB’s indecision as both a character flaw and a political statement, questioning whether anyone can really remain untouched by their times.
Cinematographer Christopher Blauvelt frames 1970s New England in muted amber tones, creating static images that echo the stillness of Arthur Dove’s paintings, the very works JB intends to steal. Dove, America’s first abstract painter, functions as JB’s silent mirror.
Where Dove distilled natural forms into motion, JB reduces motion into meaninglessness. The irony is clear: he’s a copyist chasing art’s residue without believing in creation itself.
Also read: Palma Draws the Line: No More Party Boats and Airbnb Boom Halted
Throughout, Reichardt’s direction exhibits her signature restraint. Every decision unfolds slowly, each scene thick with silence that threatens to snap. JB moves through the film like a ghost, a man who thinks apathy might protect him from chaos. Yet his refusal to choose makes him complicit in everything he ignores.
JB Mooney: The Architect of Avoidance
Josh O’Connor’s performance captures the fragile absurdity of detachment. JB is intelligent, charming, perhaps even talented, but comfortable in permanent hesitation. He isn’t driven by greed. The heist is a dare to himself, a test of feeling in a world that has numbed him.
His wife Terri, played warmly by Alana Haim, sees the void behind his calm. Their home scenes buzz with tender distance; love exists, but purpose has long escaped them.
JB’s father, portrayed by Bill Camp, embodies another kind of avoidance. A respected judge, he condemns crime at the dinner table yet fails to recognize the small moral erosions around him.
His comment about “not understanding how anyone expects riches from theft” lands with an irony that cuts deep once we know who’s listening. JB’s crime comes not from poverty but from paralysis, a rebellion against significance.
His crew, Ronnie (Javion Allen), Larry (Cole Doman), and Guy (Eli Gelb), function less as accomplices than reflections of his instability. Ronnie’s impulsiveness drives the group toward chaos, while Larry and Guy hesitate, sensing the emptiness beneath JB’s plan.
When Ronnie later cracks under pressure, betraying JB’s name to the police, it feels like the only logical outcome of an operation led by someone allergic to conviction.
Reichardt situates these misfits inside carefully composed frames that repeatedly obstruct the viewer’s gaze. JB is filmed through curtains, reflected in mirrors, or dwarfed by windowpanes, reinforcing his psychological isolation.
Even when surrounded by people, he behaves as if moving through an aquarium, visible yet untouched. The film’s physical texture becomes psychological space, a portrait of a man wrapped in the fabric of his own indecision.
Cornettist Rob Mazurek’s jazz score teases at the energy the film refuses to release. Initially airy and ironic, it grows darker as JB’s house of cards collapses. The music, like JB himself, pretends sophistication while masking dread.
When the robbery finally takes place, it’s framed with dry humor: an elderly couple mistakes the crew for janitors, and a lone security guard is barely conscious. The absurdity undercuts the tension, reminding us that the act itself is meaningless. There’s no pursuit of greed or justice, just motion without direction.
Kelly Reichardt’s Political Sleight of Hand
Reichardt’s greatest trick is disguising a moral essay within the shell of a genre film. On the surface, The Mastermind appears to be a slow heist set in the pre-disco seventies. Yet underneath the stillness lies a critique of political avoidance that feels painfully relevant.
Throughout her career, Reichardt has dissected American quietude, from Wendy and Lucy’s economic despair to First Cow’s dreamlike capitalism. Here, she shifts from the rural Northwest to suburban Massachusetts, trading pastoral settings for patterned carpets and sun-faded wallpaper.
Yet her preoccupation with moral inertia remains. JB’s decision to remain uninvolved during a decade defined by activism mirrors modern reluctance to confront societal collapse. The 1970s setting feels less nostalgic than cyclical, suggesting that every era produces its own brand of apathy.
The director’s patience allows meaning to accumulate through details rather than dialogue. A television quietly broadcasts footage of Cambodia while JB hides in a boarding house.
Later, he waits near a bus stop illuminated by a military recruitment poster. Each image whispers the same message: history keeps knocking, even when one refuses to answer.
When JB ultimately flees to the rural retreat of Fred and Maude, played by John Magaro and Gaby Hoffman, Reichardt presents him with an escape hatch, an invitation to a commune across the border where draft dodgers, feminists, and artists coexist.
Fred calls them “nice people,” offering him a way to belong. JB declines. His neutrality, by then, feels pathological. He interprets safety as passivity, mistaking resignation for freedom. His refusal signals that apathy itself has become ideology.
The film’s title grows increasingly ironic. JB is no criminal genius but a void surrounded by thinkers and rebels. The real mastermind is Reichardt, using the framework of theft to expose how privilege permits withdrawal. For JB, refusing to commit to politics, art, or family is not peace; it’s moral decay disguised as calm.
A Study of Stillness and Consequence
By the time The Mastermind reaches its closing scenes, JB is stripped of illusion. His makeshift team has imploded, his family drifts away, and his elusive neutrality collapses into absurdity.
When he finally pauses to breathe, it’s in shadow, the soft hum of television static filling the silence. Nothing explodes. No chase unfolds. The punishment for apathy, Reichardt suggests, is simply emptiness.
The film’s pacing requires patience but rewards introspection. Even its humor carries melancholy, highlighting how human folly thrives in banality. An art theft becomes a mirror for indecision.
A jazz score doubles as self-mockery. Every quiet beat drips with irony, building toward the revelation that doing nothing is itself a moral choice.
Reichardt’s aesthetic mastery makes The Mastermind one of her most sophisticated works to date. Every frame feels deliberate, every silence engineered.
Josh O’Connor, whose performances often channel suppressed emotion, proves an ideal fit. His JB is a man performing calmly while drowning beneath it. The performance anchors the film’s subtle rhythm, balancing humor with ache.
Ultimately, The Mastermind asks a question that still lingers in modern times: can one ever stay truly neutral when surrounded by injustice?
Reichardt’s answer is a quiet but firm no. Neutrality, she argues, is an illusion, a luxury that collapses under the weight of reality. JB’s tragedy lies not in failure but in absence. He becomes a ghost in a story that never demanded his death, only his choice.
Also read: New York’s Airbnb Ban: How Local Law 18 Changed the City’s Housing Market
