For Shonen Jump’s The Elusive Samurai, the general opinion is that it is one of the most surprising and beautiful anime debuts of Summer 2024. The series is known for its stunning animation, vibrant colors, and a diverse cast of characters whose humor balances the intense violence of the historical Kenmu Restoration period.
However, the animation quality in episode #4 has been criticized, with similar issues appearing in episode #5.
The Elusive Samurai quickly became popular after its first episode, which increased demand for the original manga by Yusei Matsui. The series is praised for its visuals, including a cinematic presentation and an animation style that emphasizes movement, resulting in beautiful battles and a joyful feel even in chaotic scenes.
Despite the series introducing popular characters like Suwa Yorishige, the use of CGI in episodes 4 and 5 is noticeable, and some viewers find it disappointing compared to the series’ traditionally elegant animation.
Mixed Reactions Over Animation Quality and Effectiveness
Although CGI can be effectively used in anime, its presence in these episodes contrasts with the series’ usual graceful and creative handling of movement, such as in Tokiyuki’s intense fight with Muneshige Godaiin. However, the use of CGI in the archery challenge between Tokiyuki and Sadamune, which takes place in a confined space with moving targets, is somewhat understandable.
As users on X discuss the episode, they highlight both positive and negative aspects of the animation. It’s reasonable to argue that this animation sequence might have been difficult or unrealistic to achieve with traditional methods. On the positive side, the animation features strong modeling and effective POV shots.
However, it also has drawbacks, such as flat backgrounds and lifeless 3D motion. Some users find this approach jarring, with one comparing it to “a horse kick in the face,” especially when considering how well 3D CG can work in shows like Kengan Ashura.
Uncertainty Surrounds Future Use of 3D CG After Mixed Reactions
It’s unclear if 3D CG will be used again. It was applied in situations where traditional methods might have resulted in static or dull visuals. Episode #5 of The Elusive Samurai ends the archery challenge and returns to traditional animation, raising questions about whether similar changes will occur in the future.
Thankfully, 3D CG is still rare in the series and not as dominant as in some other adaptations, like Berserk, where poor 3D CG has led many to believe it’s best left unadapted.
Given the series’ diverse and exciting combat scenes, including a thrilling chase in episode #6, it’s understandable for fans to be concerned, especially newcomers. The Elusive Samurai is generally strong enough to keep viewers engaged beyond the first three episodes, though moments like these can be unsettling.
As such, the use of 3D CG in this case is a minor but noticeable issue, much less frustrating than waiting through multiple seasons for improvements, as seen with other anime.
